Guide

Is $15,000 too much for a roof?

Short answer: for many metro Atlanta homes, $15,000 for architectural shingles is a fair price. For a small or simple roof, it is high. Here is how to tell.

Updated 2026-11-21 · Sources linked in the text and on the methodology page.

Where $15,000 lands by home size

Architectural shingles, one-story home, medium pitch, one old layer removed, permit included, metro Atlanta prices:

Home sizeRoof squares (est.)Fair range$15,000 is…
1,200 sq ft14.1$6,700 – $12,400Well above
1,500 sq ft17.6$8,300 – $15,300Fair
1,800 sq ft21.1$10,000 – $18,300Fair
2,000 sq ft23.5$11,100 – $20,300Fair
2,400 sq ft28.2$13,300 – $24,300Fair
3,000 sq ft35.2$16,600 – $30,200Below fair
3,500 sq ft41.1$19,300 – $35,100Well below

Pitch and old layers change the answer

Same 2,000 sq ft home, different roofs:

RoofFair range$15,000 is…
Medium pitch, 1 old layer$11,100 – $20,300Fair
Steep (8–9/12), 1 old layer$13,300 – $26,000Fair
Steep, 2 old layers$14,600 – $30,200Fair
Very steep (10/12+), 2 old layers$17,700 – $39,900Below fair

How to check your own $15,000 quote

  1. Find the square count on the quote ("24 SQ" means 24 squares, 2,400 sq ft of roof). Divide $15,000 by it. Architectural shingles typically run $400–$600 per square installed (HomeGuide), plus $100–$300 per square to tear off one layer.
  2. Check what is included: tear-off, underlayment, drip edge, flashing, permit, cleanup, and a per-sheet decking price.
  3. Compare at least three bids on the same square count and scope.

What national averages say

HomeGuide reports a national average of $10,800 for an asphalt roof, with most jobs between $5,700 and $16,000. Fixr puts the average at about $10,000 (range $7,500–$14,000) and HomeAdvisor at $9,611 (range $5,903–$13,380). So $15,000 is above the national average, but national averages include many smaller roofs.

Check your own quote

Enter your quote, ZIP and roof details. You get a fair range, where your price falls, and what to ask the roofer. Free, about one minute, nothing is saved.

Check my roof quote

Common questions

Is $15,000 a lot for a new roof?

It is above national averages ($9,600–$10,800 depending on the source), but it is a fair price for a mid-size or larger architectural shingle roof in metro Atlanta. For a small or simple roof it is high.

How do I know if my roof quote is too high?

Divide the price by the number of squares and compare it with typical per-square prices for your material, then check what is included. Our free checker does this for you.