Methodology
How we calculate a fair roof price
Every number the estimator uses, where it comes from, and which ones are our own judgement calls.
All sources below were opened and checked on 2026-11-21. The estimator's numbers live in `data/price-data.json`. Anything marked Judgement call is Oki's reasoned choice based on the cited sources, not a figure published by anyone.
How the fair range is calculated
- Roof squares. If the quote lists squares, we use that number. Otherwise: (home square feet ÷ stories) × slope factor × 1.05 for overhangs. The slope factor is √(1 + (rise/12)²), using rise 4, 6, 9 or 12 for the four pitch choices. HomeGuide's table (2,000 sq ft home → 2,235 sq ft of roof at 6:12) matches the slope factor; the 1.05 overhang allowance is a judgement call consistent with Angi (1,490 sq ft home → 1,800 sq ft of roof) and HomeAdvisor (roof ≈ 1.1–1.2 × house size).
- Price per square = (installed price for the material + tear-off for the old layers) × metro factor × pitch multiplier × stories multiplier. Low and high ends are calculated separately.
- Extras (decking, skylights, gutters, permit) are added at national prices with no metro adjustment.
- Totals are rounded to the nearest $100. "Typical middle" is the midpoint of the range.
- Verdict bands (judgement call): below 80% of the low end = "well below"; below the low end = "below"; inside the range = "fair" (split into lower, middle and upper thirds); up to 120% of the high end = "above"; more than 120% = "well above".
Price data
| ID | Number used | Value | Source | URL | Date checked |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| S2 | 3-tab asphalt shingles, installed | $3–$5 / sq ft = $300–$500 per square | HomeGuide, "How Much Does a Roof Replacement Cost? (2026)", Kristen Cramer, Nov 7, 2025 | homeguide.com/costs/roof-replacement-cost | 2026-11-21 |
| S2 | Architectural shingles, installed | $4–$6 / sq ft = $400–$600 per square | HomeGuide (same page) | link | 2026-11-21 |
| S2 | Standing-seam metal, installed | $9–$16 / sq ft = $900–$1,600 per square | HomeGuide (same page) | link | 2026-11-21 |
| S2 | Corrugated / sheet metal panels, installed | $5–$12 / sq ft = $500–$1,200 per square | HomeGuide (same page) | link | 2026-11-21 |
| S2 | Concrete tile, installed | $7–$19 / sq ft = $700–$1,900 per square | HomeGuide (same page) | link | 2026-11-21 |
| S2 | Clay tile, installed | $8–$25 / sq ft = $800–$2,500 per square | HomeGuide (same page) | link | 2026-11-21 |
| S2 | Old roof removal (first layer) | $100–$300 per square (shingles/metal tear-off $1–$3 / sq ft) | HomeGuide (same page) | link | 2026-11-21 |
| S2 | Lifespans | 3-tab 15–20 yrs; architectural 20–30; metal 30–80+; tile 30–100+ | HomeGuide (same page) | link | 2026-11-21 |
| S2 | Decking | $2–$5 / sq ft installed (we use $64–$160 per 4x8 sheet = 32 sq ft × $2–$5) | HomeGuide (same page) | link | 2026-11-21 |
| S2 | Skylights | Replace $800–$2,400; new install $1,600–$4,200 | HomeGuide (same page) | link | 2026-11-21 |
| S2 | Gutters | Replace $12–$25 / linear ft; new $5–$15 / linear ft | HomeGuide (same page) | link | 2026-11-21 |
| S2 | Permit | $100–$500 | HomeGuide (same page) | link | 2026-11-21 |
| S2 | Line-item checks | Drip edge $1.50–$3 / ft; underlayment material $0.10–$0.80 / sq ft; roof vent $200–$700; flashing replacement $400–$1,000; fascia $5–$12 / ft; soffit $4–$22 / ft; inspection $100–$400; truss $5–$14 / sq ft | HomeGuide (same page) | link | 2026-11-21 |
| S2 | National average (asphalt) | $10,800; typical $5,700–$16,000 | HomeGuide (same page) | link | 2026-11-21 |
| S1 | Atlanta asphalt roofing replacement | Job cost $29,851; resale $20,475; 68.6% recouped (national $31,871; South Atlantic $32,253) | Remodeling / JLC, 2025 Cost vs Value Report, Atlanta, GA | jlconline.com/cost-vs-value/2025/south-atlantic/atlanta-ga/ | 2026-11-21 |
| S1 | Atlanta metal roofing replacement | Job cost $43,826; resale $26,959; 61.5% recouped (national $51,865) | Same report and page | link | 2026-11-21 |
| S1 | What the CvV roofing job includes | 30 squares, tear-off to bare sheathing, min. 235-lb shingles, new underlayment, drip edge, flashing, rectangular hip roof, two skylights, vented ridge | JLC, "Roofing Replacement / Asphalt Shingles" project description, June 20, 2025 | jlconline.com/cost-vs-value/roofing-replacement-asphalt-shingles/ | 2026-11-21 |
| S1 | Atlanta metro factor | Asphalt 0.937 (= 29,851 / 31,871); metal 0.845 (= 43,826 / 51,865). Tile: asphalt ratio used (Judgement call, no Atlanta tile figure published) | Calculated from S1 | — | 2026-11-21 |
| S3 | Cross-check: national roof cost | Average $9,611; normal $5,903–$13,380; $4–$11 / sq ft; architectural $4–$6 / sq ft; tile $10–$20 / sq ft; removal $1,000–$3,000 + hauling $500–$1,500 | HomeAdvisor, "How Much Does Roof Replacement Cost?", updated Jun 17, 2026 | homeadvisor.com/cost/roofing/install-a-roof/ | 2026-11-21 |
| S4 | Atlanta averages | Average $7,777; most pay $5,211–$10,355; $4–$11 / sq ft; 1,490 sq ft home ≈ 1,800 sq ft roof; average Atlanta permit ≈ $175 | Angi, "How Much Does Roof Replacement Cost in Atlanta? [2026 Data]", Dan Simms, updated Jul 8, 2026 | angi.com/articles/how-much-does-roof-replacement-cost/ga/atlanta | 2026-11-21 |
| S5 | Cross-check and extra layers | Average ≈ $10,000; $7,500–$14,000; tear-off ≈ $50 per square, up to $150 for heavy or multiple layers; labor 40–60% of cost; solar remove/reinstall $500–$2,000 | Fixr, "How Much Does a Roof Replacement Cost? [2026 Data]", updated Feb 4, 2026 | fixr.com/costs/roof-replacement | 2026-11-21 |
| S12 | Steep-roof labor (used for the pitch judgement) | Past 8/12, labor +15–30%; very steep can nearly double labor time | American Commercial Roofing (an Atlanta contractor, so treat as an industry opinion), updated Oct 4, 2026 | americancommercialroof.com/...atlanta-metro/ | 2026-11-21 |
Judgement calls (not published figures)
- Extra old layers: $50–$150 per square per extra layer, based on Fixr's ≈$50 average tear-off and "up to $150 for multiple layers".
- Pitch multipliers: steep (8–9/12) ×1.07–1.15; very steep (10/12+) ×1.15–1.35. Reasoning: S12's 15–30% labor increase × Fixr's 40–60% labor share ≈ 6–18% of total; very steep is set higher because S12 says labor can nearly double.
- Stories multipliers: 2-story ×1.00–1.05; 3+ stories ×1.05–1.10. HomeGuide lists multiple stories as a cost factor but gives no number.
- Overhang allowance: ×1.05 (see method above).
- Tile metro factor: uses the asphalt ratio 0.937.
- Verdict bands: 80% / 120% thresholds.
- Deposit red flag: we flag deposits over 30%. No Georgia deposit limit was found; HomeGuide advises not paying in full upfront.
Rules, laws and safety (used in red flags)
| ID | Fact | Source | URL | Date checked |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| S6 | Talk to your insurer before repairs or inspection; be skeptical of deductible offers; roofers may not file claims unless they are or employ a licensed public adjuster; SB 201 (effective July 1, 2025): within 1 year of a natural disaster, contractors may not take assignment of insurance proceeds and must honor cancellation before midnight of the 5th business day after a written claim denial, with a Notice of Cancellation form | Georgia Attorney General's Consumer Protection Division, "Storms and Fraud" | consumer.georgia.gov/consumer-topics/storms-fraud | 2026-11-21 |
| S7 | Georgia does not require a roofing license; a legitimate roofer should provide references, business license, workers' comp, general liability, tax ID, written warranties, permanent address and phone | Georgia AG Consumer Ed, Feb 4, 2025 | consumered.georgia.gov/ask-ed/2025-02-04/... | 2026-11-21 |
| S8 | Roofers are specialty occupations not licensed by the state; general liability required for licensed contractors; workers' comp with 3+ employees | Georgia AG Consumer Ed, Dec 13, 2023 | consumered.georgia.gov/ask-ed/2023-12-13/... | 2026-11-21 |
| S10 | Misdemeanor to advertise or promise to pay or rebate any part of an insurance deductible, including a yard-sign discount | O.C.G.A. § 33-23-43(c)(4), (d), (e), via Justia (2025 Georgia Code) | law.justia.com/.../section-33-23-43/ | 2026-11-21 |
| S2 | Don't pay in full upfront; get 3+ estimates; get written estimate, contract and warranty | HomeGuide (roof replacement page) | link | 2026-11-21 |
City housing data
| ID | Data | Source | URL | Date checked |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| S11 | Median year built (B25035), year built distribution (B25034), median home value (B25077), tenure (B25003), units in structure (B25024) for the 10 cities | U.S. Census Bureau, ACS 2020-2024 5-year estimates, retrieved through the Census Reporter API (raw file: `data/acs2024_5yr_raw.json`) | api.censusreporter.org | 2026-11-21 |
Sources looked at but not used for numbers
- RSMeans city cost indexes: not publicly available for free, so not used.
- Roofer and SEO blog pages (e.g. theroofingbrief.com, domroofing.com, mustangroof.com) quote Atlanta prices but are marketing or unverified aggregators. They were read only as a sanity check. Their Atlanta ranges ($8,000–$20,000 for typical homes) are close to our results.